NJ Spotlight: China, Canada Beat U.S. on Equity

Updated November 2026

NJ Spotlight Q&A on PISA 2025: China and Canada do better educating disadvantaged 15-year-olds. What falling U.S. reading scores mean for NJ schools.

PISA 2025 reading drop stings — equity lessons for NJ parents

New Jersey parents who treat international rankings as dinner-table fuel just got a clearer brief. In a Q&A published by NJ Spotlight News, education systems researcher Tracey Burns of the National Center on Education and the Economy walked through the newest PISA cycle: a global exam of 15-year-olds in reading, math, and science taken across 91 countries and economies. Her blunt conclusion is that places like China, Canada, Estonia, Ireland, and South Korea are doing a better job educating the most disadvantaged students, not only the already strong.

American teens' reading scores dropped about 14 points since 2022 and sit near a 25-year low, Burns told NJ Spotlight. On PISA's rough scale, about 20 points equals a year of schooling, so a 14-point slide is roughly two-thirds of a year — six to eight months behind prior cohorts. Math and science did not drop as sharply for the U.S., she noted, so the alarm is concentrated in reading, the skill that carries every other subject.

What top systems do differently

Burns points to coherence: Singapore and other high performers align classrooms, lessons, teacher quality, and leadership instead of running disconnected pilots. Top systems recruit teachers from stronger applicant pools; she affirmed reporting that China draws heavily from the top 10% to 30% of college graduates while the U.S. leans on the lower-middle tier. Teaching carries higher social status in many Asian systems, which changes who applies and who stays.

Equity is not only a test-prep story. Burns said high performance paired with equity shows up in China, Canada, Estonia, Ireland, Japan, Korea, and Macao. Those systems more often connect schools to health, nutrition, and safety supports so students furthest from opportunity can actually learn when the bell rings. Belonging — real relationships with teachers and peers — is a recurring driver. The U.S., she argued, still struggles to scale pockets of excellence across a large, fragmented map.

Homework is not the simple villain or hero. More homework helps up to about two hours a day for 15-year-olds, then returns decline. Many top systems average near the U.S. figure of about 1.4 hours; Singapore and Korea run closer to two. Teacher pay matters as recognition, Burns said, but American teachers earn less than 60% of similarly educated U.S. workers, far below the wealthy-nation average for relative pay — and pay alone cannot fix a broken system past a point.

What NJ districts can take from it

The Q&A is useful for New Jersey because it separates two questions that often get blurred: how the strongest students score, and whether the system serves poor kids well. Burns's China and Canada examples are not a call to import every policy wholesale. They read more like a checklist: teacher pipeline quality, deployment of strong teachers into hard schools, cross-sector supports, and AI used to build skill rather than replace reading practice.

On AI, Burns flagged Korea as a system where students reported relatively high AI use and still scored well — evidence that instruction can teach augmentation instead of shortcuts. For New Jersey districts working on literacy, the practical questions are local: Who coaches reading teachers? Which schools get the strongest teachers? Do the students who need them get transport, meals, and health supports?

What this means for you

• Read the full Q&A: NJ Spotlight News.

• U.S. reading ~14 points down since 2022 (~2/3 year of schooling).

• Watch district literacy plans, teacher coaching, and how top teachers are assigned — not only elite track seats.

• Treat AI as a skill to teach, not a homework replacement; ask schools how they set rules.

• Check your school board agenda: equity items matter even if your child is already high-performing.

The story under the ranking is whether disadvantaged 15-year-olds can read well enough to keep every other door open.

Tags: education, nj, pisa, china, canada, equity, schools, 2026

Sources: NJ Spotlight News — Tracey Burns Q&A, NJ Spotlight News, National Center on Education and the Economy