Best Ice Cream in NJ (2026): 10 Shops Still Open in Winter, From Fort Lee Rolls to Edison Kulfi

By Bao You-Know

Ten New Jersey ice cream shops still open in winter, from Fort Lee rolled ice cream and gelato to Edison kulfi, Denville Dairy, and Nicholas Creamery.

When the boardwalk stands close for the season, a shorter list of New Jersey ice cream shops keeps regular winter hours, or stays open all year. This is a directory of ten of those shops, not a ranked endorsement. Addresses, hours and phone numbers are below. Confirm before you go, especially around the holidays.

The mix includes Thai rolled ice cream and gelato in Fort Lee, kulfi and a classic parlor in Edison, a handmade year-round shop in Denville, Nicholas Creamery on the Shore, a small-batch case in Princeton, and OddFellows in Montclair. For pastry on the same trip, see our guide to the best bakeries in NJ. Late-night dessert stops are in the NYC and NJ late-night eats guide. Seasonal frozen-custard stands, including the two official Kohr family lines, have their own history and map and are not repeated here. Looking for New York City shops that stay open in winter? See our separate list of 10 ice cream shops still open in winter in NYC.

The 10 shops

#ShopWhereWhat to tryHoursLink
1Jinn Ice Cream Rolls, Fort LeeFort LeeThai rolled ice creamSun–Thu noon–10 p.m.; Fri–Sat noon–11 p.m.Official site
2Butter & Scoop, Fort LeeFort LeeGelato; matcha or ubeDaily 7 a.m.–10 p.m.Official site
3Kwality Ice Cream, EdisonEdisonMalai or mango kulfiOpen all year; call aheadOfficial site
4Denville Dairy, DenvilleDenvilleHandmade hard ice creamClosed Mon; Tue–Thu & Sun 11 a.m.–9:30 p.m.; Fri–Sat 11 a.m.–10 p.m.Official site
5Scoop To My Lou, East Brunswick and South PlainfieldEast Brunswick / South PlainfieldHandmade hard ice cream or soft serveWinter: noon–9 p.m. daily; open all yearOfficial site
6Nicholas Creamery, Fair Haven and six more NJ shopsFair Haven (plus six NJ shops)Valrhona Chocolate or Tahitian VanillaFair Haven: Sun–Thu noon–9:30 p.m.; Fri–Sat noon–10 p.m.Official site
7The Bent Spoon, PrincetonPrincetonSmall-batch ice cream or sorbetFall 2026: Mon–Tue noon–5; Wed–Thu noon–9; Fri–Sat noon–10; Sun noon–9Official site
8The Ice Cream House, EdisonEdisonA banana split or a sundaeSun 1–9 p.m.; Mon–Thu 2–9 p.m.; Fri 2–10 p.m.; Sat 1–10 p.m.Official site
9Shivers Ice Cream, HowellHowellHard or soft ice creamYear-round; Sun–Thu noon–9 p.m.; Fri–Sat noon–10 p.m.Official site
10OddFellows Ice Cream, MontclairMontclairSprinkles or Peanut Butter S'moresMon–Thu 2–10 p.m.; Fri 2–11 p.m.; Sat noon–11 p.m.; Sun noon–10 p.m.Official site

1. Jinn Ice Cream Rolls, Fort Lee

Rolled green-tea ice cream packed in a white paper cup at Jinn Ice Cream Rolls
Photo: Jinn Ice Cream Rolls / jinnicecreamrolls.com (shop photo)

Jinn is at 304 Main Street, Fort Lee, NJ 07024, phone (201) 592-7733. Hours are Sunday through Thursday, noon to 10 p.m., and Friday and Saturday, noon to 11 p.m. The shop makes Thai-style rolled ice cream: cream poured onto a chilled plate, chopped with mix-ins, and rolled into spirals in front of you.

Build a roll with mix-ins such as fresh fruit, boba, candy, nuts and drizzles, or start with a set flavor such as cookies and cream if you would rather not design one from scratch. This is a sitting-and-watching order, not a grab-and-go scoop, so give yourself a few extra minutes on a busy weekend evening. Ask at the counter for prices.

2. Butter & Scoop, Fort Lee

A scoop of green tea gelato in a yellow cup with a cone tucked on the side
Photo: Butter & Scoop / butterandscoop.com (shop photo)

Butter & Scoop is a few doors down the same street, at 250 Main Street, Fort Lee, NJ 07024, phone (973) 630-0363. The shop is open every day from 7 a.m. to 10 p.m., the earliest winter opening on this list. It is both a bakery and a creamery: salt bread baked on the premises, gelato (32 flavors), and Korean-style bingsu.

If you are here for ice cream, start with a gelato scoop — matcha or ube if you want a flavor that sits next to the bakery case, or lemon, a favorite of Louie K. of Fort Lee. Ube Cream and Matcha White Chocolate Ganache are among the cream-filled breads if you want something to eat with the scoop. “We came here with our family for ice cream, and it was absolutely delicious! Every flavor was rich, creamy, and full of flavor.” — Sandra R., Fort Lee, NJ, butterandscoop.com

3. Kwality Ice Cream, Edison

Staff scooping ice cream from tubs of yellow, pink and white flavors at Kwality Ice Cream
Photo: Kwality Ice Cream / kwalityfoods.com (shop photo)

The Edison parlor is at 1734 Oak Tree Road, Edison, NJ 08820, phone (732) 906-1941. The parlor is open all year. Call before you go.

Kwality has more than 56 flavors and specializes in kulfi, cassata, falooda and eggless ice cream cakes. Signature kulfi comes in Malai, Kesar, Pista, Rose, Paan and Mango. Spicy guava and meetha paan are popular scoops, and malai kulfi is the dense, slow-cooked classic. A first order can be a malai kulfi or a mango scoop, then a falooda if you want the rose, noodles and rabdi combination. Ask at the counter for prices.

4. Denville Dairy, Denville

Ice cream sundaes in clear cups, topped with chocolate sauce and colorful candies
Photo: Denville Dairy / denvilledairy.com (shop photo)

Denville Dairy is at 34 A Broadway, Denville, NJ, phone (973) 627-4214. The shop has made ice cream by hand for more than 60 years, and it is open year-round. Regular hours are Tuesday through Thursday and Sunday, 11 a.m. to 9:30 p.m., and Friday and Saturday, 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Monday is closed.

This is a classic parlor stop: handmade hard ice cream, rotating flavors, cakes, and a soft chocolate-vanilla swirl if you want what Krista J. always orders in a cone with sprinkles. Ask to taste a couple of scoops before you decide. “Hands down the best ice cream around. Doesn't matter if it's regular or fat/sugar free it is good. Friendly staff and owners. Love that they are open year round.” — Kim A., denvilledairy.com

5. Scoop To My Lou, East Brunswick and South Plainfield

A row of chocolate-dipped ice cream cones, some rolled in sprinkles, in a display case
Photo: Scoop To My Lou / scoop2mylou.com (shop photo)

Scoop To My Lou has two New Jersey shops, and both are open all year. East Brunswick is at 59 Main Street, East Brunswick, NJ 08816, phone (732) 955-0808. South Plainfield is at 228 Hamilton Boulevard, South Plainfield, NJ 07080, phone (908) 941-4444. Winter hours for both locations are noon to 9 p.m. every day. The shops accept cash and credit cards.

The shops serve handmade hard ice cream and soft serve, plus cones, cups, sundaes, shakes and ice cream cakes. The East Brunswick shop has an open-air garden for a pre- or post-meal dessert when the weather allows. In winter, treat that garden as a maybe and plan to take a cup or a cone inside. Ask at the counter what is in the case that day.

6. Nicholas Creamery, Fair Haven and six more NJ shops

A scoop of Tahitian Vanilla ice cream in a cup at Nicholas Creamery
Photo: Nicholas Creamery / nicholascreamery.com (shop photo)

Nicholas Creamery's Fair Haven shop is at 586 River Road, Fair Haven, NJ 07704, phone (732) 852-2033. Hours there are Sunday through Thursday, noon to 9:30 p.m., and Friday and Saturday, noon to 10 p.m. The creamery also lists shops in Atlantic Highlands (84 1st Avenue, 732-204-2340), Tinton Falls (1201 Sycamore Avenue, 848-456-4035), Long Branch (444 Ocean Boulevard North, Long Branch, NJ 07740, 732-272-1098), Middletown (1500 Route 35, Unit 19, 848-225-3476), Wall (2435 Route 34, Unit 11, Manasquan; opens at 11 a.m.), and North Brunswick on Grand Avenue, phone (732) 243-9069. Call the North Brunswick shop for the exact entrance before you go.

Signature flavors include Valrhona Chocolate and Tahitian Vanilla. Other regulars on the list are Hudson Café Coffee Crunch, Bourbon Chocolate Chunk, Nutty Monkey, Malted Cookies N Milk, and Vegan Coconut Cherry Vanilla. “A little gem!! Delicious ice cream…every flavor we have tried has been amazing.” — Jill G., nicholascreamery.com

7. The Bent Spoon, Princeton

A waffle cone packed with chunky ice cream at The Bent Spoon
Photo: The Bent Spoon / thebentspoon.com (shop photo)

The Bent Spoon is at 35 Palmer Square, Princeton, NJ 08542. For questions, email getbent@thebentspoon.com. Fall 2026 hours are Monday and Tuesday, noon to 5 p.m.; Wednesday and Thursday, noon to 9 p.m.; Friday and Saturday, noon to 10 p.m.; and Sunday, noon to 9 p.m. Confirm hours before you go, especially around later holidays.

This is a small-batch ice cream and sorbet shop. Flavors start on the case and change, so ask what is being scooped that day rather than arriving with one locked-in name. A cone with a chunky mix-in is a solid first order if you want what the shop often shows in its photos. thebentspoon.com

8. The Ice Cream House, Edison

A banana split sundae with whipped cream and cherries at The Ice Cream House
Photo: The Ice Cream House / theicecreamhousenj.com (shop photo)

The Ice Cream House is at 940 Amboy Avenue, Edison, NJ 08837, phone (732) 709-3002. Posted hours are Sunday, 1 to 9 p.m.; Monday through Thursday, 2 to 9 p.m.; Friday, 2 to 10 p.m.; and Saturday, 1 to 10 p.m. Use those posted hours, and call ahead if you are going on a holiday week.

The shop lists more than 40 flavors, plus sundaes, shakes and cakes. A banana split is a clear first order if you want the parlor classic the shop shows in its photos; a shake or a simple sundae also works if you are splitting the table with kids. This is a second Edison stop on the list, on a different stretch of town from Kwality. theicecreamhousenj.com

9. Shivers Ice Cream, Howell

Chocolate-dipped ice cream cups lined up at Shivers Ice Cream
Photo: Shivers Ice Cream / shiversicecream.com (shop photo)

Shivers Ice Cream is at 4037 Route 9 North, Howell, NJ 07731, at Route 9 North and Aldrich Road, phone (732) 415-8126. The shop is open year-round. Hours are Sunday through Thursday, noon to 9 p.m., and Friday and Saturday, noon to 10 p.m.

The stand serves hard and soft ice cream, frozen yogurt, Italian ice, shakes and cakes. A chocolate-dipped cup or cone is an easy first order if you want what the shop often photographs; a soft-serve swirl or a hard scoop works if you are feeding a mixed table. This is a Route 9 stop, useful if you are already driving that corridor in winter. shiversicecream.com

10. OddFellows Ice Cream, Montclair

A close-up of an OddFellows ice cream cone
Photo: OddFellows Ice Cream Co. / oddfellowsicecream.com (shop photo)

The Montclair shop is at 450 Bloomfield Avenue, Montclair, NJ 07042. Hours are Monday through Thursday, 2 to 10 p.m.; Friday, 2 to 11 p.m.; Saturday, noon to 11 p.m.; and Sunday, noon to 10 p.m. For questions, email hello@oddfellowsmontclair.com.

OddFellows is known for classic flavors with a twist. Sprinkles and Peanut Butter S'mores are a clear place to start from the flavor list; ask what else is in the case that day if you want a rotating scoop. This is the New Jersey shop on the list; the same company's Chelsea shop is on our NYC winter ice cream list. oddfellowsicecream.com

Good to know

Call or check with the shop before you go, especially in the week of Christmas and New Year's. Two Fort Lee shops sit on the same stretch of Main Street, and Edison appears twice, at Kwality and The Ice Cream House, on different roads. Some shops post year-round hours; others post a winter or fall schedule, as The Bent Spoon does for Fall 2026. Scoop To My Lou takes cash and cards; ask at other counters if you are unsure. Seasonal stands such as Kohr Bros. are not on this winter list; they have their own history and map. New York City shops are on a separate NYC list.

FAQ

Which ice cream shops in New Jersey stay open in winter?

This directory lists ten shops that post winter hours or stay open all year, including Jinn Ice Cream Rolls and Butter & Scoop in Fort Lee, Kwality Ice Cream and The Ice Cream House in Edison, Denville Dairy, Scoop To My Lou, Nicholas Creamery, The Bent Spoon in Princeton, Shivers Ice Cream in Howell, and OddFellows in Montclair. Confirm hours before you go.

What should I try at Nicholas Creamery?

Valrhona Chocolate and Tahitian Vanilla are the signature flavors. Hudson Café Coffee Crunch, Bourbon Chocolate Chunk, Nutty Monkey, Malted Cookies N Milk, and Vegan Coconut Cherry Vanilla are also on the regular list. The Fair Haven shop is at 586 River Road; six other New Jersey shops are listed with their addresses and phones in the section above.

Is Denville Dairy open year-round?

Yes. The shop has made ice cream by hand for more than 60 years and is open year-round. Regular hours are Tuesday through Thursday and Sunday, 11 a.m. to 9:30 p.m., and Friday and Saturday, 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Monday is closed.

What are the fall 2026 hours at The Bent Spoon in Princeton?

Fall 2026 hours are Monday and Tuesday, noon to 5 p.m.; Wednesday and Thursday, noon to 9 p.m.; Friday and Saturday, noon to 10 p.m.; and Sunday, noon to 9 p.m. The shop is at 35 Palmer Square. Email getbent@thebentspoon.com with questions, and confirm hours around later holidays.

Are Jinn Ice Cream Rolls and Butter & Scoop in the same town?

Yes. Both are on Main Street in Fort Lee. Jinn is at 304 Main Street; Butter & Scoop is a few doors down at 250 Main Street. Jinn makes Thai rolled ice cream in the afternoon and evening. Butter & Scoop opens at 7 a.m. and also serves gelato, bingsu and salt bread.

Why isn't Kohr Bros. on this list?

Kohr Bros. and other seasonal frozen-custard stands close with the warm-weather season, so they are not on this winter directory. They have their own history and map.

Sources

Disclaimer: This is an editorial directory, not a paid endorsement or a personal recommendation. Hours, flavors and prices can change. Confirm with each shop before you go. Daily Bao is not affiliated with these businesses. Corrections: contact@dailybaonews.com.

How many of these 10 have you tried? Which is your favorite? Which shop did we miss? Comment below.